Thursday, December 3, 2009

Thanksgiving Pie...Oh my!

As some regular readers of my blog may recall, I have been trying to wheedle my way into Thanksgiving Pie making for the last few years. Each year I get put in charge of the salad, which , let's face it is the least glamorous of the Thanksgiving Dishes. Aunt Jane has held the corner on pie-making for years, but in her second year as a Thanksgiving no-show, I decided to try again.
After promising to clean up after myself my mom gave the okay as long as it was okay with Grandma. Grandma also gave the thumbs up as long as I made the pies on Monday night so that I could help out with the other stuff. These conditions worked for me, and like that I was in!
But I couldn't make just any old pie. Aunt Jane would be back next year and unless my pie was truly spectacular I would be back to salads...without time to do a test run myself I decided to turn to America's Test Kitchen for a tried and true recipe:
The stakes were raised even higher when my mom confessed that a couple of frozen pies had been on her shopping list. She claimed that she bought frozen pie every year, but I had my doubts...
I started off cutting super find apples as the recipe suggested. Apple-cutting=a lot of work!
Then I went on to making my own pie crust. Although store-bought crust had been suggested I knew that my crust had to be lighter than air - I could take no chances. I have never been so careful about measuring ingredients, leveling the measuring cup with a knife, etc. Still, the dough I was working with didn't sound like the dough described in the book. it was more like fondant-a lot softer and stickier than I would have expected.
Still, after triple-checking the recipe I couldn't find anything that I had done wrong. I continued on...
As the pies were in the oven, I noted that the crust was seeming rather fluffy. Then...as I was cleaning up after myself as promised...I discovered the culprit of my pie-making demise:
Self-rising flour! Who would have thought this was even in my mom's pantry...but it was too late. My dreams of pie glory were gone!
The pies themselves turned out okay, despite a crust that was pretty much falling apart and about a half-inch thick:


While everyone claimed they thought the pie was good, what was missing were the cries for Karin pie on an annual basis. Perhaps even sadder was the fact that the frozen pies were finished before mine :( Will I ever be allowed to make Thanksgiving pie again or is it back to salad for me??

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Maybe next year you can just add apples to your salad:)

Jennifer said...

Or maybe we could have a salad pie?

Grandma K said...

Karin, your apple-cranberry pie was such a hit that it was gone before I even had a chance to taste it. I'll probably let you make more pie next year.

Jennies Aunt Liz said...

Karin, I loved your thick and flakey apple pie. I warmed it up, put a little drop of ice cream on it and delicious! You can bake a pie for me any day. I do not like to bake.

Doggy said...

oops!!! I bought that self rising flour when I made my cupcakes at good friday. My bad Karin. But your pies were great!!

Sara Rechtin-Wiercinski said...

Remember the episode of Friends when Monica makes lasagna for her mom's party, only to lose a press-on nail in the dish? Sounds like your pie experience was much better than Monica's catering job.